Loyalty Programs: Creating and Maintaining Long-term Customers

Pizzerias are neighborhood fixtures, serving the community as a friendly hotspot to dine in or to order take out. People tend to select a favorite pizza place and stick to it for a variety of reasons: preferred pizzas and toppings, convenient location, speedy delivery, the atmosphere of the restaurant itself, or for the excellent loyalty program.

Every pizzeria strives to have loyal customers as they are the building blocks of a sustainable, profitable business. Capturing loyalty is the initial feat of making programs lucrative, but maintaining that loyalty can be rather difficult.

Many customers who frequent a specific pizzeria simply do not feel inclined to sign up for a loyalty program off the bat. There are a few ideas pizzeria owners can implement as ways of nudging customers into their rewards programs without being too pushy or promoting something disadvantageous to the customer:

Keep it Sweet, Direct, and Short – A major hindrance to signing up for loyalty programs is how long the pitch is or the amount of effort it takes to fill out the form. Briefly and simply introduce the customer to the loyalty program. No one wants to listen to a long speech when they’re trying to order their meal, so make sure to reach the point swiftly and illustrate how beneficial joining your pizzerias loyalty program will be. It is a good idea to just get an email first and/or phone number because quickly jotting down an email is relatively easy. Another solid tactic is to ask customers if they would like to fill out the sign-up forms while they are waiting for their meals.

Personalize the Program and Make It Fun – Creating a point system for items can generate positive buzz and making a game or competition out of it can also increase sign-ups amongst all ages. A free pizza that the customer has earned will inherently taste better because customers feel that they have earned it! Personalized programs are a good way to see what precisely is drawing in customers, such as the ambiance of the pizzeria because of live music or if the pepperoni is perfectly spicy or smoky. This is key data to improve all aspects of the restaurant’s operations.

Look to the Future with Electronic Systems – Loyalty/rewards cards are often used, but many establishments are venturing into electronic cards to elevate the level of customer retention. The traditional method of stamping loyalty cards hardly generates any interest or buzz around it. Customers end up collecting piles of half-complete cards that usually do not benefit the customer. Apps and messaging programs like Belly, Spendgo, and OpenTable allow for customers to collect their rewards without keeping track of a flimsy card. These systems are simple to set up and will soon be the norm, so it is a fantastic idea to jump ahead of the trend.

Loyalty programs are deeply engrained in successful business models. Customer retention can prove to be challenging in the face of endless competitors, which is why an emphasis on loyalty programs should be exponentially valued.

Skip to content